This article reflects ongoing discussions across the international education sector and aims to encourage constructive dialogue on student protection, financial sustainability and responsible partnerships. It does not seek to attribute the causes of individual school closures to any particular commercial practice.
The past few months have been among the most challenging in recent memory for the international education industry. The sudden closures of established education providers, including EC English, ILAC Education Group and BSC Education, have sent shockwaves through a sector built on relationships, opportunity and trust.
For many years, established brands and longstanding commercial partnerships have offered reassurance to students and agents alike. Recent events, however, have demonstrated that neither the size of an organisation nor its reputation can, on its own, guarantee financial stability or continuity of service.
The industry’s response has also revealed something remarkable. Schools have welcomed displaced students, agents have worked tirelessly to find alternatives, and sector associations have mobilised to minimise disruption. In the UK, English UK’s Student Emergency Support scheme has played an important role in coordinating replacement courses.
Yet the extraordinary goodwill demonstrated across the sector has also exposed the limitations of relying on goodwill alone. The question now is how to translate that collective commitment into more reliable and sustainable protections.
At ICEF Berlin 2026, discussions about recent school closures went beyond immediate student protection. They also challenged the sustainability of commercial practices that have become increasingly familiar across international education.
Commercial arrangements, including heavily discounted rates, volume-based commission structures and extended payment terms, have long played a role in supporting international student recruitment. Recent events, however, invite us to reconsider how these practices can be balanced with the financial sustainability of education providers.
These practices have developed for different reasons. Agents need competitive pricing to attract students in price-sensitive markets, while schools depend heavily on international recruitment partners to reach students around the world. Volume-based incentives can reward successful partnerships, and flexible payment arrangements can support business growth.
Nevertheless, when substantial discounts are combined with high commissions and extended payment terms, the financial pressure on providers can become significant. Schools must still pay teachers, support staff, accommodation suppliers, landlords and operational costs, regardless of when payments arrive.
This does not mean that any particular commercial arrangement caused the recent closures. Each company’s circumstances are different. It does, however, raise an important question about the future of the industry: are we sometimes prioritising recruitment volumes and short-term competitiveness over long-term sustainability?
A growing number of conversations suggest that the answer may lie not simply in selling more student weeks, but in creating commercially balanced partnerships capable of delivering quality and continuity.
One of the most complex questions concerns payment terms.
Schools understandably require sufficient cash flow to deliver the services they have promised. At the same time, students and agents need reassurance that money paid months in advance will remain protected should a provider cease trading.
The recent closures have highlighted the risks associated with both extremes. Requiring substantial advance payments without adequate safeguards can leave students financially exposed. Conversely, allowing extensive deferred payments may place unsustainable pressure on schools expected to deliver services before receiving the corresponding revenue.
Could a more structured instalment-based system offer a reasonable compromise?
As StudyTravel Magazine reported in October, some agency representatives have suggested paying for courses in shorter blocks, rather than transferring the entire programme fee long before students arrive.
Such an approach deserves consideration, but it also raises further questions. Which services genuinely require advance payment? How far in advance should those payments be made? Should money be released to providers progressively as services are delivered? And who should hold and protect funds before they are released?
There may be no universal solution. However, transparent contracts, proportionate deposits, clearly defined payment milestones and independently managed financial safeguards could provide a stronger foundation for future agreements.
For students booking longer programmes, particularly those lasting 24 weeks or more, accommodation can represent the largest component of their total investment.
It is also among the most difficult elements to protect when a school closes.
In several recent cases, students and agents have faced additional accommodation costs despite having already paid their original provider. Some replacement arrangements have been offered at reduced rates, reflecting the generosity of accommodation partners, but this does not eliminate the financial burden on those affected.
The problem is particularly complicated because accommodation providers often require their own deposits, guarantees and advance commitments. Schools may therefore have legitimate financial obligations to third-party suppliers well before students arrive.
Simply postponing all accommodation payments until after a student’s stay may not be realistic. Equally, asking students to prepay many months of accommodation without adequate financial protection is increasingly difficult to justify.
A more sustainable approach could involve separating tuition and accommodation payments, clarifying which sums are held by the school and which have been committed to third parties, and exploring arrangements that protect funds until accommodation is provided or an appropriate guarantee is in place.
For long-term students, financial security must cover the entire educational experience, not simply the classroom.
One of the most thought-provoking perspectives to emerge from discussions at ICEF Berlin was the willingness expressed by some agency representatives to reconsider commission expectations if doing so could contribute to better quality, greater financial stability and continuity of service.
This deserves serious attention.
For an agent, recommending a school is rarely just a commercial transaction. It involves relationships developed over years, an understanding of a student’s ambitions and the confidence to recommend a provider to families making significant financial commitments.
A higher commission may make a partnership commercially attractive, but it cannot compensate for the consequences of a school failing to deliver.
This leads to a straightforward question: if a provider offers exceptionally low prices and unusually high commissions, what reassurance can it offer that sufficient resources remain to deliver the promised quality and services?
The answer should not simply depend on the size of the brand, the strength of a personal relationship or the assurances of a sales representative.
Agents increasingly need meaningful evidence of financial resilience. However, that creates another challenge: who should independently assess schools’ financial health, how frequently should those assessments take place, and what level of assurance could realistically be provided?
Independent financial reviews, appropriate reporting requirements and transparent risk assessments are potential avenues worth exploring. Yet no financial check can eliminate risk entirely, and any system must balance meaningful oversight with confidentiality, proportionality and the operational realities of schools of different sizes.
While financial safeguards and commercial structures are essential, the industry’s most important asset remains its people.
Every student week represents someone who has made a personal investment in education, often with the support of parents or relatives who have saved for months, sometimes years, to make that experience possible.
Studying abroad is more than learning a language. It can represent independence, improved employment prospects, personal development and opportunities that may otherwise remain out of reach.
When a school closes unexpectedly, those aspirations are placed at risk. Students may suddenly face uncertainty about their courses, accommodation and ability to remain in their chosen destination.
The human consequences extend well beyond students. Teachers, administrative teams and commercial staff may find themselves facing immediate financial and professional uncertainty. For some employees affected by school closures, the uncertainty extends to outstanding payments, contractual entitlements and the immediate challenge of securing alternative employment. Their experiences deserve recognition alongside those of displaced students and education partners.
Education agents also face difficult conversations with families whose trust they have worked hard to earn, often while trying to resolve situations over which they have little control.
These are not simply operational inconveniences or unfortunate commercial consequences. They affect livelihoods, wellbeing and futures.
People are not merely part of the international education industry. They are the industry.
And any meaningful discussion about rebuilding trust must begin by recognising their importance.
The sector’s response to the recent closures has demonstrated the value of collective action, particularly through the work of English UK and schools that have offered replacement courses.
However, questions remain about the extent to which emergency support arrangements can protect prepaid accommodation, future bookings and the financial interests of students and receiving institutions.
On 28 October, English UK announced a major Student Protection Review, involving providers, agents, students and specialist advisers. The review is considering a range of possible mechanisms, including insurance, escrow arrangements, guarantees, funds and hybrid solutions.
Across the sector, member schools and education partners are keenly awaiting the findings of English UK’s review, hopeful that its recommendations will provide a clearer path towards stronger student protection and renewed confidence in international education.
This is an important development, particularly because the discussion is moving beyond emergency responses towards defining what protection students should reasonably expect before committing to an international education experience.
The challenge will be finding an approach that offers genuine reassurance without creating financial obligations that smaller providers cannot sustain or inadvertently introducing new risks into the system.
Schools and agents will need to contribute constructively, recognising that protecting students and supporting financially sustainable education providers are not competing priorities. They are interdependent.
The future of international education cannot be built on fear, nor should it be defined solely by the failures of individual organisations.
The sector continues to offer life-changing opportunities to students from around the world, supported by thousands of dedicated professionals and responsible providers.
For London, one of the world’s leading destinations for English language education, maintaining that confidence is especially important.
The discussions at ICEF Berlin reinforced the need for more transparent relationships between schools and agents, clearer expectations around financial commitments and a stronger understanding of the responsibilities shared across the student journey.
Individual businesses must remain free to determine their own pricing and commercial arrangements. Nevertheless, the industry can work together to develop stronger standards for student protection, financial transparency, communication and responsible partnership management.
Lower prices alone do not guarantee value. Higher commissions do not necessarily create better partnerships. And a globally recognised brand is not, by itself, a substitute for demonstrable financial safeguards.
What matters most is whether every organisation involved can deliver on the commitments it makes.
Perhaps the most important lesson from recent events is that trust cannot be sustained by personal relationships alone, however valuable those relationships may be.
It must be supported by responsible commercial decisions, meaningful financial protections, transparent communication and accountability towards everyone involved.
The willingness of schools, agents and industry associations to question established practices reflects a sector determined to learn, adapt and strengthen its foundations.
As the international education community looks towards 2027, the conversation should not simply focus on recovering lost student numbers or restoring growth.
It should focus on ensuring that the next generation of students can invest in international education with genuine confidence, and that the people and organisations delivering those experiences can build a sustainable future.
Because the true measure of our industry’s success lies not only in the student weeks we deliver, but in the trust we earn, the commitments we honour and the opportunities we create for the people who place their futures in our hands.